Are Pit Bulls Misunderstood?
If you’ve never spent time with pit bulls, you may still have general assumptions about the breed. That they are dangerous. Mean. Shouldn’t be around children. And so many more stereotypes generally applied to all members of the breed. But where did those come from and are they fair?
October is National Pit Bull Awareness Month so Run Those Dogs is here to say we’ve met and cared for a whole lot of sweet, goofy, wonderful pit bulls that defy all the negative stereotypes.
As with any dog or animal you don’t know, use caution and avoid making them feel unsafe or uncomfortable. As with all breeds, socialization and training are of utmost importance to teach a dog how to safely interact with children and adults. Our hope is that by sharing this information about pits, you’ll do your best to keep an open mind about the breed.
Arin Greenwoods article about pit stereotypes points out that applying stereotypes to the entire breed has a real cost on the dogs themselves and their families. “Hundreds of jurisdictions across the country ban or otherwise restrict ownership of these dogs — which leads to dogs being taken away from their families for nothing more than their appearance, and families living in fear of losing their beloved pets.” She adds that even where ownership is legal, finding housing may be difficult. They are among the most common breeds in shelters with the longest stays and among the breeds most likely to be euthanized, perhaps more than 3000 per day in the U.S.
But where did Pit Bull’s bad rap come from?
As Roy Rivenberg wrote in his L.A. Times article, “Petey, the canine sidekick in the Little Rascals comedies, was a pit bull. So were the mascots for RCA Victor and Buster Brown shoes. Even the White House welcomed pit bull offshoots under Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson.”
There are plenty of pit bull heroes as well who’ve saved people from fires, excelled as service animals for the disabled and in the military, and extended and brightened the lives of millions of pet parents. They just aren’t making headlines as often. So how did we come to present day where the breed is banned in some cities and counties?
Were they bred for violence? “Pit bull terriers are a cross between English bulldogs, which were bred in the 1800s to fight bulls and bears with tenacious bites to the snout, and terriers, known for speed and agility. The combination produced dogs that deliver a “crushing bite” and don’t let go,” explains Nicholas Dodman. He’s the director of the animal behavior clinic at Tufts University’s school of veterinary medicine and author of Dogs Behaving Badly in Rivenberg’s article.
In fact their rap has been made notorious by real, deadly attacks against toddlers and adults — including the fatal mauling of an Antelope Valley woman in 2013. But Rivenberg adds, “…numerous studies show pit bulls are no more likely to bite humans than other breeds.”
But just as we shouldn’t broadly believe stereotypes about humans, nor should we with pit bulls.
In fact members of the ‘pit bull’ label can encompass the Staffordshire bull terrier, American Staffordshire terrier and American pit bull terrier, among other breeds. As you might have guessed, individual dogs within a breed can vary widely in personality, temperament and a host of other traits. Just as widely as within any other breed.
Defenders blame bad owners for the negative headlines. Pit bulls have risen to the top as the breed symbolizing rebellion and toughness and some owners choose it for that reason.
But in fact, pit bulls haven’t always held this top spot in our shifting culture. “In the 1800s, bloodhounds were reportedly the most feared breed. In the 1970s, German shepherds ranked as dog-bite kings,” says Rivenberg. So wouldn’t these facts imply that as our companions (and weapons), its not the breed that is dangerous but the behaviors that we as humans choose to teach them?
Is their bad rap truly deserved? Maybe not. And more importantly can it be overcome with time, education, positive training and socialization? We think so.
Meet Run Those Dogs Client Jesse the Pit
Jessie is a pure-bred pit. Her humans Greg and Danniell knew the moment they saw her as a puppy in 2009 that she was the one. While her brothers and sister ran back over to their mother, Jessie came right over with her tail in rapid fire mode. Her pet parents remember her as the cutest and most inquisitive, a trait that still (for better or worse) remains today.
Since she was a puppy, Jessie still spends most nights sharing the bed with their son. “People often ask if she is OK to have around a family. My youngest was five, and my oldest was seven when we got her, and there has never been a single instant during which she was anything other than their best friend and protector. She loves to be hugged and petted, and she often returns the favor with a well-placed tongue to the face,” explains Greg.
Jessie is full of personality. “Over the years, her exuberance has never waned, and her love for her humans has only grown. I cannot tell you how many rough days at work have been instantly washed away by this beautiful, little girl presenting me with her favorite bone as I entered the door,” adds Greg. “She has a knack for detecting sadness or depression in her humans, and never lets it go unacknowledged.”
Run Those Dogs loves that we can support this family when they need it, feeding and playing with Jessie and her lab buddy Rowdy when their pet parents travel. They are such sweet hearts!
Jessie is more than a dog to Greg and Danniell. “You may have noticed that I don’t refer to her as our dog. We are her humans. She is a part of our family, and will always hold a cherished spot in our hearts.”
We hope you won’t generalize the reputation of a breed to every dog within it. And go one better. Be sure to acknowledge and spread the word when you meet a kind and lovable pit. They are out there. We’ve met quite a few and they deserve their chance at happiness.